Supply chain transformation and technology management challenges in developing regions: Inductive theory building from rural Chinese nanostores

Abstract

Rural nanostores are the dominant source of packaged products for consumers in rural China, thus the more these stores order from reliable suppliers, the better the product quality available to rural areas. To improve merchandise circulation in rural areas, the Chinese government embarked on the large‐scale “Thousands of Villages” (ToV) program in 2005. One of its key components was the implementation of an information technology (IT) procurement system to facilitate transactions between rural nanostores and the ToV program's certified consumer packaged goods (CPG) suppliers. The nanostores' adoption of the ToV procurement system was encouraged yet voluntary. We study how this system was used initially and how it evolved over time. If effective, this program has the potential to address the growing social disparity between rural and developed areas in China. We first embarked on an exploratory analysis (March 2012) to understand the ToV program from the perspectives of nanostore owners, the ToV's CPG suppliers, and the government. We then collected interview data. In Period 1 (2013–2014), when the technology was still nascent, we found that nanostore owner's trust in the ToV's CPG suppliers, and system value, played key roles for nanostore owners to use the ToV procurement system. In Period 2 (2018–2019), three contextual factors emerged—population demographic shift, improved technology infrastructure, and trust in new [non‐ToV] purchasing platforms—each hindering the ToV procurement system's use. We observed strong government support during the early phases of ToV, but that support evolved from subsidizing the ToV platform and offering associated training (Period 1), to also providing credibility to competing non‐ToV procurement platforms (Period 2). Collectively, the findings identify idiosyncratic challenges that arise when public policies attempt to address developing region problems by reengineering supply chains via IT. We provide implications for IT research about technology management in rural developing areas and for managers to recognize potential pitfalls of managing IT projects in supply bases unfamiliar with advanced IT.

Digital capabilities to manage agri-food supply chain uncertainties and build supply chain resilience during compounding geopolitical disruptions

“…Existing contributions to digital transformation (Holmström et al, 2019;Schroeder et al, 2020;Warner & Wäger, 2019;Guo et al, 2022;Kabbiri et al, 2018) refute the notion that small entities can achieve higher strategic digital transformation. These studies place little focus on digital dynamic capabilities at the interorganizational level.…”

“…Notable digital tools include Big Data Analytics (BDA), Artificial Intelligence (AI), blockchain, smart sensors, the Internet of Things (IoT), and Additive Manufacturing (AM). Despite extensive research on digital innovation in supply chain management, the unique challenges of African AFSC in vulnerable regions are under-studied by IS/OM scholars (Dong, 2021;Guo et al, 2022), a gap that needs attention given the pressing issues like population growth and climate change in these regions. Moreover, the effectiveness of digital technologies in developed countries' supply chains may not fully translate to vulnerable regions like Africa (Guo et al, 2022).…”

“…Despite extensive research on digital innovation in supply chain management, the unique challenges of African AFSC in vulnerable regions are under-studied by IS/OM scholars (Dong, 2021;Guo et al, 2022), a gap that needs attention given the pressing issues like population growth and climate change in these regions. Moreover, the effectiveness of digital technologies in developed countries' supply chains may not fully translate to vulnerable regions like Africa (Guo et al, 2022). The OM literature has yet to explore the link between digital technologies and SCRes, especially in contexts like African AFSC (Shen & Sun, 2021).…”

Improving the greenness of enterprise supply chains by designing government subsidy mechanisms: based on prospect theory and evolutionary games

“…Currently, due to the defects in market mechanisms and constraints of individual business interests, the development of green supply chains faces numerous obstacles. For instance, small rural retailers in developing countries face challenges related to supply chain reform and technology management ( Guo et al, 2022b ). In this context, decision-making for green supply chain enterprises involves various complexities, such as cost reduction, interlinking interests, and adapting to dynamic market environments.…”

The Nano Revolution: IT and Supply Chain Integration in Small Retailers in the Middle East

“…As the retail industry becomes increasingly digital and consumer preferences shift towards seamless experiences, the role of IT in influencing nanostore performance becomes crucial. IT is employed to improve the customer experience at nanostores by simplifying tasks such as placing orders and conducting transactions [9]. This may involve adopting technologies, such as electronic data interchange (EDI), enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems, and supply chain management (SCM) software, to facilitate real-time data exchange and collaboration.…”