Avidocin-CDs are a new class of precision bactericidal agents that do not damage resident gut microbiota and are unlikely to promote the spread of antibiotic resistance. The precision killing properties result from the fusion of bacteriophage receptor binding proteins (RBPs) to a lethal contractile scaffold from an R-type bacteriocin. We recently described the prototypic Avidocin-CD, Av-CD291.2, that specifically kills C. difficile ribotype 027 strains and prevents colonization of mice. We have since selected two rare Av-CD291.2 resistant mutants of strain R20291 (RT027; S-layer cassette type-4, SCLT-4). These mutants have distinct point mutations in the slpA gene that result in an S-layer null phenotype. Reversion of the mutations to wild-type restored normal SLCT-4 S-layer formation and Av-CD291.2 sensitivity; however, complementation with other SCLT alleles did not restore Av-CD291.2 sensitivity despite restoring S-layer formation. Using newly identified phage RBPs, we constructed a panel of new Avidocin-CDs that kill C. difficile isolates in an SLCT-dependent manner, confirming the S-layer as the receptor in every case. In addition to bacteriophage adsorption, characterization of the S-layer null mutant also uncovered important roles for SlpA in sporulation, resistance to lysozyme and LL-37, and toxin production. Surprisingly, the S-layer-null mutant was found to persist in the hamster gut despite its completely attenuated virulence. Avidocin-CDs have significant therapeutic potential for the treatment and prevention of C. difficile Infection (CDI) given their exquisite specificity for the pathogen. Furthermore, the emergence of resistance forces mutants to trade virulence for continued viability and, therefore, greatly reduce their potential clinical impact.