Avalanches in sandpiles are represented throughout a process of percolation in a Bethe lattice with a feedback mechanism. The results indicate that the frequency spectrum and probability distribution of avalanches resemble more to experimental results than other models using cellular automata simulations. Apparent discrepancies between experiments are reconciled. Critical behavior is here expressed throughout the critical properties of percolation phenomena.PACS numbers: 64.60 Fr, 64.90 +b, 84.90 +n
INTRODUCTIONThe idea of self-organized criticality (SOC) proposed by Bak, Tang and Wiesenfeld [1,2] triggered a lot of experimental as well as theoretical work on relaxation processes in granular materials. Sandpiles seem to be the simplest systems to test self-organized behavior. The importance of its study comes from the fact that SOC has been suggested as a possible explanation for the power law behavior seen in many systems: earthquakes, [3] mass distribution in the Universe, star flickers, etc. [4] Experiments on sandpiles were designed and performed in [5,6]. In [5], avalanche sizes were recorded in rotating drum experiments, finding that avalanches, instead of being distributed over all sizes obeying a power law distribution as predicted in [1,2], occurred quite regularly in size and time, in an almost periodic pattern (See also [7,8]).In [6], mass fluctuations in an evolving sandpile were studied, showing that for small enough sandpiles, the observed mass fluctuations are scale invariant, and probability distribution of avalanches shows finite size scaling whereas large sandpiles do not. In this experiment, small sandpiles seemed to exhibit SOC. Besides, an apparent disagreement has emerged between the results reported in [5] and [6] but, as we will show in this paper, these results are essentially the same.Though many other theoretical and experimental works were performed [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28], some of the later proposed models were devoted to the problem of SOC in a more general fashion than the sole application to sandpiles (e.g. [9,10,12,16]). Some others fix their attention in models for which particular mechanisms of interaction seem to be relevant [13][14][15]18,21,28].In the present work we propose a representation of the avalanche process in sandpiles as a percolation in a Bethe lattice, capturing the essential features of the avalanche phenomenon and simultaneously taking into account the nature of the sandpile, in order to reproduce the experimental results.The image of an avalanche as an initial object that consecutively drags another resembles a branching process for which the Bethe lattice representation seems to be natural. This branching process was proposed in [22], showing good possibilities to describe the change of behavior of fragment size distribution in fragmentation phenomena. Another branching process representation was proposed in [12,26] in an attempt to obtain analytical solutions for avalanche processes, and in [23,24], a...