Appendicular diverticulitis (AD) is a rare entity characterized by the inflammation of the arising diverticulum of the appendix. It has been reported to carry a high risk of perioperative complications, such as bleeding and perforation. Furthermore, multiple articles have highlighted the importance of diagnosing AD early due to its strong association with malignancies. Limited published cases concerning AD in our country and globally are available in the literature. Hence, we present in this article a case series of five exciting cases of incidental findings of AD that were initially diagnosed as acute appendicitis based on clinical evaluation and imaging findings. In our series, we performed a retrograde evaluation of the computed tomography scans of all five cases that showed diverticula. In conclusion, histopathological evaluation remains the method of choice to reach the definitive diagnosis; however, it is essential to highlight the relevance of imaging in diagnosing AD preoperatively in the early stages to reduce morbidity and mortality.