Survey of Osteopathic Medical Students Regarding Physician Shadowing Experiences Before and During Medical School Training

Abstract

Introduction: Shadowing a physician is an observational experience which includes a student observing a licensed healthcare provider caring for patients. Shadowing is commonly done by students before and during medical school, but little is known about the nature or extent of these extra-curricular observational experiences. Objective: We hypothesized that shadowing experiences were common yet variable. We investigated the prevalence, nature, and perceived value of medical student experiences with shadowing physicians (both before and during medical school). Methods: This survey-based study was non-experimental with a cross-sectional convenience sample of osteopathic medical students about their shadowing experiences before and during medical school. The survey was sent to all matriculated osteopathic medical students (OMS1-4) for the 2017 to 2018 academic year from two medical schools: Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine (PCOM) (1084 total students) and PCOM-Georgia (554 total students). The final survey instrument included three sections: demographics (6 questions), pre-medical shadowing experiences (21 questions), and medical student shadowing experiences (24 questions). Results: Respondents (357) identified themselves as OMS1 (96), OMS2 (89), OMS3 (73), OMS4 (95) and other (2, OMS5) with enrollment at PCOM-Philadelphia (242) and PCOM-Georgia (115). Among survey respondents, 339 (95.5%) reported shadowing a physician as a pre-medical student, and 110 (30.8%) reported shadowing (outside of their required clinical rotations) a physician during medical school. Requirements to participate were inconsistent; fewer than 50% of shadowing experiences required Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) training, proof of vaccination, or purified protein derivative (PPD) documentation. In addition to observation, pre-medical and medical students, respectively, participated in history taking (44 [13%], 47 [42.7%]), physical examinations (45 [13.3%], 44 [40%]) and procedures (13, [3.8%], 20 [18.2%]) during their shadowing experiences. Motivations to participate in shadowing varied between pre-medical and medical student experiences, but both groups mentioned their desire to learn more about a particular discipline, obtain letters of recommendation, and gain patient care experience. Students recommended both pre-medical (273 [80.5%]) and medical school (93 [84.5%]) shadowing to future students. Conclusion: Shadowing remains a common and important tool for students to learn about patient care, medicine and careers. The nature of each shadowing experience and participation requirements are quite variable. Measures to ensure patient safety, confidentiality, liability and supervision are inconsistently applied. Promoting guidelines, as well as codes of conduct, for shadowing could serve as a helpful resource for students, academic advisors and supervising clinici...

Modified organized ophthalmology pre-internship in China

“…The significance of early involvement of medical students for clinical practice cannot be overemphasized (16). Preinternship is crucial for medical students and is a rewarding experience (17)(18)(19). Most of students participating in medical pre-internship have little medical knowledge and are curious about the role as a clinician (20).…”

Physician Shadowing: An Essential Practice in Fostering the Doctors of Tomorrow

“…The large majority of medical students endorse that shadowing experiences before medical school increased their desire to attend medical school. 3,12,13,14 Shadowing experiences can also be gateways for students to develop career mentors and obtain a letter of recommendation for medical school. 3,10,15 This aspect is crucial, especially for those students from disadvantaged backgrounds who may have less connections to the medical field.…”

“…3,12,13,14 Shadowing experiences can also be gateways for students to develop career mentors and obtain a letter of recommendation for medical school. 3,10,15 This aspect is crucial, especially for those students from disadvantaged backgrounds who may have less connections to the medical field. 2,16 New, innovative techniques to enhance shadowing experiences are being developed.…”

“…At a small liberal arts college, 80% of premedical students had at least one shadowing experience 2 , and at an osteopathic medical school, 95.5% of students shadowed as a premedical student. 3 As admissions to medical school become more competitive, shadowing experiences become crucial so that schools can ensure they are accepting students who understand the challenges that come with being a doctor. However, finding shadowing experiences is challenging, as the increased administrative burden can disincentivize physicians from offering these opportunities.…”

Examining career shadowing in genetic counseling: Perspectives of shadowees, program directors, and genetic counselors

“…A study of 102 students at a liberal arts college revealed 80.2% of pre-medicine students had experience with shadowing (Adams O'Connell & Gupta, 2006). Langenau et al (2019) found 95.5% of osteopathic medical students reported shadowing a physician as a pre-medical student. It is unclear, however, the percentage of GCs who shadowed a GC prior to entering a graduate program.…”