Aquagenic palmoplantar keratoderma (APPK) classically presents as exaggerated wrinkling of the palms after brief immersion in water that lasts 10 minutes to a few hours. We present a case report of a 19-year-old female who presented with peeling, sensitivity, and pain on her palmar hands, most prominently on her fingertips, that persists for several minutes to an hour after touching water. This case highlights a unique presentation of APPK predominantly involving the patient’s palmar fingertips, a distribution not described in the literature. Current therapies are unsatisfactory and better therapies are needed to improve the quality of life for patients with APPK.