Synovial cysts are rare, and they occur even more rarely bilaterally or in the cervical spine. A 38-year-old previously healthy female presented with acute onset of numbness and tingling down her arms and weakness in her legs, which progressed steadily over 2-3 weeks to include significant gait disturbance. She denied bowel or bladder symptoms, saddle anesthesia, night sweats, weight loss, fever, or chills. MRI spine revealed a C7-T1 extradural mass consistent with bilateral synovial cysts emanating from bilateral neuroforamina resulting in critical spinal cord compression with T2 signal change in the cord. There was questionable patch enhancement after gadolinium contrast. The patient underwent C7-T1 laminectomies and partial bilateral medial facetectomies with excision of the cysts. Intraoperative cultures unexpectedly grew Staphylococcus aureus, suggesting superinfection of cysts. The patient recovered neurologic function postoperatively and was discharged on a 6-week course of IV antibiotics. We report and discuss the clinical presentation, pathogenesis, and neuroradiological findings in an adult case of bilateral synovial cysts at the C-T-spine junction. Immediate resection at symptom onset is indicated due to the good clinical outcome following resection and the real risk of paralysis if cysts are not excised in a timely fashion.