Tetracarboxylate pyrroline nitroxides undergo very fast reduction with
ascorbate/GSH, with second order rate constants that are five orders of
magnitude greater than those for gem-diethyl pyrroline
nitroxides. For tetracarboxylate nitroxides, the electrochemical reduction
potentials, measured by square wave voltammetry, are much less negative (by
about 0.8 V), compared to the corresponding gem-diethyl
nitroxides, while the oxidation potentials become more positive (by about 0.7
V). Electrochemical potentials correlate well via simple regressions with
field/inductive parameters such as Swain/Lupton F-parameters (and/or Charton
σI-parameters). Rates of reduction with ascorbate/GSH
similarly correlate well for four pyrroline nitroxides, except for the slowest
reducing gem-diethyl nitroxide. These results suggest that the
electron withdrawing groups adjacent to the nitroxide moiety have a strong
accelerating impact on the reduction rates, and thus they are not suitable for
the design of hydrophilic nitroxides for in vivo
applications.