A series of Ti(IV) and Zr(IV) bis(benzyl) postmetallocene precatalysts containing an unusual C(sp 3 )-chelating [O,N,CH(Ar)] ligand has been synthesized. The four-membered N,C-donor chelate is anticipated to engender more accessible active sites, while the aryl-substituted C(methine) moiety can introduce an element of flexibility therein. The racemic complexes have been fully characterized by multinuclear NMR spectroscopy. In particular, [ 1 H, 19 F]-COSY and -HOESY experiments were conducted to elucidate the environment around the fluorine atoms at the aryl substituent. The molecular structures of two Zr derivatives have been determined by X-ray crystallography, which confirm their C 1 -symmetric nature and the relatively small tridentate bite angle. With regard to ethylene polymerization reactions in conjunction with trityl borate at 22 °C, the [O,N,CH(Ar)]-Ti catalysts exhibit high activities (up to 820 g mmol −1 h −1 atm −1 for Ar = 2-fluorophenyl) and are more efficient than the C(sp 2 )-chelating [O,N,C(σ-aryl)] congeners, and the 2,4,6-trifluorophenyl catalyst produces a polymer (M w = 3.3 × 10 2 kg mol −1 ) with an M w /M n value of 2.3. Although evidence of C−H•••F−C contacts corresponding to "weak attractive ligand−polymer interactions" has not been found for these catalysts, this study illustrates the beneficial effects arising from ortho (especially fluorine) substituents on the arylmethine moiety.