“…(path E and F) Comparing the energy profiles of four paths (path A, C, E and F) together in Scheme 2, we can see that although the reaction process of dehydrogenation has fewer elementary steps than dehydration, the PTSA-mediated dehydration of HCOOH catalysed by Pd-py t bpx is obviously more favourable than the corresponding dehydrogenation, owing to the much lower apparent activation energy of path A than E. Such advantage is unaffected under the PTSA-free reaction conditions, since the dehydrogenation of 2a-py t bpx should be accomplished by HCOOH instead of PTSA (via TS4b-py t bpx instead of TS4a-py t bpx), which rationalizes the stable chemoselectivity to CO by Pd-py t bpx under the PTSA-absent conditions. In sharp contrast to the observed remarkable stability of Pd-py t bpx catalyst, 25,33,34 the catalyst of Pd-d t bpx is always prone to decompose in either the absence or the presence of PTSA under heating conditions, which leads to the formation of Pd nanoparticles (i.e., Pd black). 34,35 Such distinction on stability is more obvious under the water-contained acidic conditions.…”