“…According to the first experiments (Table 1), Cinchonaalkaloid based phase transfer catalysis was less effective than tertiary amine base organocatalysis (entries 1,3 vs entries 2,4), while 2-formyl benzonitrile was more promising than 2formyl methylbenzoate, giving a good er of 92/8 with high diastereoselectivity (dr>20/1) and good yields in the presence of 10 mol% of 7 (Entry 4). Despite the longer synthetic pathway, the use of 2-formyl benzonitrile has the additional advantage of allowing the access to another class of interesting heterocycles 5 with the imidate functionality, 12 which was then conveniently converted into the phthalide 3 by hydrolysis. The screening of conditions, performed with catalyst 7, led to the identification of xylene as the best solvent for this system, and after the optimization of medium concentration, a very good 95/5 er was obtained (Entry 6).…”