A comparative experimental and computational study examining the interplay of the ancillary ligand structure and Ni oxidation state in the Ni-catalyzed C(sp 2 )−O crosscoupling of (hetero)aryl chlorides and primary or secondary aliphatic alcohols is presented, focusing on PAd-DalPhos (L1)-, CyPAd-DalPhos (L2)-, PAd2-DalPhos (L3)-, and DPPF (L4)ligated [(L)NiCl] n (n = 1 or 2) and (L)Ni(o-tol)Cl precatalysts. Both L1 and L2 were found to outperform the other ligands examined, with the latter proving to be superior overall. While Ni(II) precatalysts generally outperformed Ni(I) species, in some instances the catalytic abilities of Ni(I) precatalysts were competitive with those of Ni(II). Density-functional theory calculations indicate the favorability of a Ni(0)/Ni(II) catalytic cycle featuring turnover-limiting C−O bond reductive elimination over a Ni(I)/ Ni(III) cycle involving turnover-limiting C−Cl oxidative addition.