The circular dichroic (CD) profile characterizing unordered polypeptide chains and denatured proteins is the subject of much current attention. Tiffany and Krimm,' and Rippon and Walton2 have suggested that the doubly dichroic CD spectrum (positive band near 218 nm and a much larger negative band near 200 nm) obtained in ionized polyL-glutamic acid [(Glu),] and in polyl-lysine [(Lys),] chains characterize not an unordered conformation (abbreviated as U), but rather a conformation that contains regions of left-handed 31 helical order called the extended helix (abbreviated as EH). This conformational assignment was based on the similarity of this doubly dichroic CD profile with that of the polyL-proline I1 helix. Potential energy calculations, including ionic terms, on ionized (G~u),,~*( and also on ionized (Gl~-Ala),~ have yielded conformational minima for these ionized polymers at (+, $ ) 6 = 84O, 321", and 74O, 343", respectively, compared to the value 103", 326' for the polypropline I1 helix. These similarities in conformational parameters and CD spectra have led Rippon and Walton2 to conclude that the presence of a positive Cotton effect near 218 nm and a negative one near 200 nm is diagnostic of a polypeptide with 31 helical segmental order, i.e., the E H conformation.On the other hand, several workers'-9 have argued thqt the EH-type CD spectra are in fact representative of unordered structures, and that "much or all the CD data of Tiffany and Krimm may be interpreted fts mixtures of helical and unordered forms, and will not require invocation of a third structural form."8 We had observed earlier9 the ubiquity of the doubly dichroic CD spectra in a variety of polypeptides, both ionized and nonionic, under a variety of conditions. That such EH-type spectra might arise in diverse situations such as charge repulsions, protonation, or solvent binding has been claimed recently by Tiffany and Krirnm.lo However, in two recent important papers, Miller et al." have shown that under the conditions of residual blocking groups, concentration, and ionic strength of the medium, (Glu), is indeed not in the E H form, but is a random coil.Additional credence for the latter point of view is provided by the circular dichroic spectra of poly-&taspartic acid and poly-7-bglutamic acid that we present in Figure 1. These two polymers are variants of the usual poly-a-peptide sequence in that the former has an extra methylene group in the primary structural backbone, while poly-y-bglutamic acid has two methylene groups. Yet, as the figure reveals, both poly-8-lraspartate and poly-y-bglutamate display doubly dichroic spectra similar to those seen in ionized (Glu), or (Lys),. (The CD spectra of the acid forms of these two poly-w-peptides are interpreted in terms of a third Cotton effect, induced on the carboxylic acid chromoph0re.12,'~) Qualitatively similar CD spectra are exhibited by ionized copoly-(ybGluyaminobutyric acid),14 and also by the tertiary butyl esters of both these poly-w-amino acids in hexafluoroisopropanol. The additi...