Systematic Analysis of Impact of Sampling Regions and Storage Methods on Fecal Gut Microbiome and Metabolome Profiles

Abstract

The contribution of human gastrointestinal (GI) microbiota and metabolites to host health has recently become much clearer. However, many confounding factors can influence the accuracy of gut microbiome and metabolome studies, resulting in inconsistencies in published results. In this study, we systematically investigated the effects of fecal sampling regions and storage and retrieval conditions on gut microbiome and metabolite profiles from three healthy children. Our analysis indicated that compared to homogenized and snap-frozen samples (standard control [SC]), different sampling regions did not affect microbial community alpha diversity, while a total of 22 of 176 identified metabolites varied significantly across different sampling regions. In contrast, storage conditions significantly influenced the microbiome and metabolome. Short-term room temperature storage had a minimal effect on the microbiome and metabolome profiles. Sample storage in RNALater showed a significant level of variation in both microbiome and metabolome profiles, independent of the storage or retrieval conditions. The effect of RNALater on the metabolome was stronger than the effect on the microbiome, and individual variability between study participants outweighed the effect of RNALater on the microbiome. We conclude that homogenizing stool samples was critical for metabolomic analysis but not necessary for microbiome analysis. Short-term room temperature storage had a minimal effect on the microbiome and metabolome profiles and is recommended for short-term fecal sample storage. In addition, our study indicates that the use of RNALater as a storage medium of stool samples for microbial and metabolomic analyses is not recommended. IMPORTANCE The gastrointestinal microbiome and metabolome can provide a new angle to understand the development of health and disease. Stool samples are most frequently used for large-scale cohort studies. Standardized procedures for stool sample handling and storage can be a determining factor for performing microbiome or metabolome studies. In this study, we focused on the effects of stool sampling regions and stool sample storage conditions on variations in the gut microbiome composition and metabolome profile.

Comparing Metabolomics Profiles in Various Types of Liquid Biopsies among Screening Participants with and without Advanced Colorectal Neoplasms

“…Samples were processed according to a standard protocol within 4 h which ensures best possible sample quality. We avoided freeze–thawing cycles by taking wet stool from the frozen total samples but other researchers prefer homogenizing or drying the stool samples before doing metabolomics analysis to decrease variability [ 36 ].…”

The effects of dairy and dairy derivatives on the gut microbiota: a systematic literature review

“…RNA later) may lead to disruptions in sequencing results, such as decreased species relative abundance. 56,57 Additionally, studies differed significantly in terms of methods used to extract bacterial DNA, which can influence DNA yield, purity, and ultimately, microbiome outcomes. 58,59 As such, this may have also influenced the results.…”

A Guide to Diet-Microbiome Study Design

“…The collection of the entire bowel movement may be important for some studies considering that the distribution of microbial species in a single bowel movement is not homogenous (76, 77). Fecal sampling location within a single stool sample may affect the abundance of specific microbes, reflecting the diverse microbial communities residing in small niches throughout the gastrointestinal tract (78). Collection of the entire bowel movement presents significant logistical challenges including the need for study participants to collect and transport large sample volumes.…”