To better understand the binding interaction between antigen and antibody we need to distinguish protein residues critical to the binding energy and mechanism from residues merely localized in the interface. By analyzing the binding ofmonoclonal antibodies to recombinant wild-type and mutant myohemerythrin (MHr) proteins, we were able to test the role ofindividual critical residues at the highly antigenic site , within the context of the folded protein. The results directly show the existence of antigenically critical residues, whose mutations significantly reduce antibody binding to the folded protein, thus verifying peptide-based assignments of these critical residues and demonstrating the ability of buried side chains to influence antigenicity. Taken together, these results (i) distinguish the antigenic surface from the solvent-exposed protein surface before binding, (ii) support a two-stage interaction mechanism allowing inducible changes in protein antigens by antibody binding, and (iii) show that protein antigenicity can be significantly reduced by alteration of single critical residues without destroying biological activity.Antigenic epitopes ofproteins are composed of continuous or discontinuous portions of the polypeptide chain. The discontinuous epitopes are formed by two or more noncontiguous segments brought into proximity by the folding ofthe protein.Although much attention has been paid to epitope mapping and characterization of epitopes, there is still no agreement on the precise definition and the make-up of an epitope or on the best ways to identify antigenic epitopes (1-3). It has been suggested that experimental approaches that rely on the linear sequence of the protein to locate and define antigenic determinants would miss many biologically significant sites (4, 5). However, since all discontinuous epitopes contain continuous segments, the study of short peptides can give important information about more complex determinants (6). Indeed, recent studies using peptide-based assays have identified the antigenically important portions of such discontinuous sites (7-13), even to the resolution of single critical amino acids within these sites (14,15). Studies have also shown that antibodies (Abs) to pathogens, including human immunodeficiency virus (16) and foot-and-mouth-disease virus (17), can recognize or be induced by linear or sequence continuous epitopes.In our studies of the myohemerythrin (MHr) protein, we have used synthetic peptides to identify a set of amino acid residues that are critical to the immune response, in that their omission or replacement in component peptides results in loss of reactivity with polyclonal and monoclonal anti-MHr Abs (15,18,19). However, there has been no direct experimental evidence, for MHr or any other protein antigen (Ag), to verify whether amino acid residues that are identified as antigenically critical by the peptide-based approach are indeed critical within the context of the folded protein. Here, we test directly the correlation between criti...