Systems-Level Annotation of a Metabolomics Data Set Reduces 25 000 Features to Fewer than 1000 Unique Metabolites

Abstract

When using liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry (LC/MS) to perform untargeted metabolomics, it is now routine to detect tens of thousands of features from biological samples. Poor understanding of the data, however, has complicated interpretation and masked the number of unique metabolites actually being measured in an experiment. Here we place an upper bound on the number of unique metabolites detected in Escherichia coli samples analyzed with one untargeted metabolomics method. We first group multiple features arising from the same analyte, which we call "degenerate features", using a context-driven annotation approach. Surprisingly, this analysis revealed thousands of previously unreported degeneracies that reduced the number of unique analytes to ∼2961. We then applied an orthogonal approach to remove nonbiological features from the data using the C-based credentialing technology. This further reduced the number of unique analytes to less than 1000. Our 90% reduction in data is 5-fold greater than previously published studies. On the basis of the results, we propose an alternative approach to untargeted metabolomics that relies on thoroughly annotated reference data sets. To this end, we introduce the creDBle database ( http://creDBle.wustl.edu ), which contains accurate mass, retention time, and MS/MS fragmentation data as well as annotations of all credentialed features.

A Reference Feature based method for Quantification and Identification of LC-MS based untargeted metabolomics

“…RFQI is built based on three hypotheses: The number of features in a specific type of sample, i.e., urine, is finite when applying a fixed detection method, since the number of both metabolites in bio-samples and their adduct types are relatively limited 9 . The whole feature set can be assembled by grouping feature information from a certain number of samples.…”

Reactomics: using mass spectrometry as a reaction detector

“…Our concept, paired mass distance (PMD), reflects such rules by calculating the mass differences of two compounds or charged ions. Mass distances can also directly reveal isotopologue information (11), adducts from a single compound (12), or adducts formed via complex in-source reactions (13). Highresolution mass spectrometry (HRMS) can directly measure such paired mass distances with the mass accuracy needed to provide reaction-level specificity.…”

A Protocol to Compare Methods for Untargeted Metabolomics

“…Artifacts are signals that result from informatic errors. In some untargeted metabolomic experiments, contaminants and artifacts may represent a major fraction of the total LC/MS signals detected [6]. …”