A. In this paper we study the tangent space to the Hilbert scheme Hilb d P 3 , motivated by Haiman's work on Hilb d P 2 and by a long-standing conjecture of Briançon and Iarrobino on the most singular point in Hilb d P n . For points parametrizing monomial subschemes, we consider a decomposition of the tangent space into six distinguished subspaces, and show that a fat point exhibits an extremal behavior in this respect. This decomposition is also used to characterize smooth monomial points on the Hilbert scheme. We prove the first Briançon-Iarrobino conjecture up to a factor of 4 3 , and improve the known asymptotic bound on the dimension of Hilb d P 3 . Furthermore, we construct infinitely many counterexamples to the second Briançon-Iarrobino conjecture, and we also settle a weaker conjecture of Sturmfels in the negative.
IThe Hilbert scheme of d points in P n , denoted by Hilb d P n , parameterizing closed zerodimensional subschemes of P n of degree d, is a projective moduli space with very rich geometry and a plethora of open questions. It was constructed by Grothendieck [G61] and shown to be connected by Hartshorne [H66]. In the case of P 2 , Fogarty [F68] proved that Hilb d P 2 is nonsingular of dimension 2d, Ellingsurd and Strømme [ES87] computed its homology, and Arcara, Bertram, Coskun, Huizenga [ABCH13] studied its birational geometry in great detail. It also has connections to other areas of mathematics, e.g. to algebraic combinatorics, where it plays a central role in Haiman's proof of the n! Conjecture [H01]. By contrast, the Hilbert scheme is singular for n ě 3 and very little is known about its geometry. The case of Hilb d P 3 is of particular interest, since it lies at the boundary between the smooth cases n ď 2 and the cases n ě 4 which are believed to be wildly pathological, see e.g. [J18]. In fact, Hilb d P 3 is known to be rather special, as it admits a super-potential description -it is the singular locus of a hypersurface on a smooth variety, cf. [BBS13]. For small d, Hilb d P 3 is irreducible, and its general point parametrizes configurations of d points in P 3 ; in particular, the Hilbert scheme has dimension 3d. However, Iarrobino [I72] proved that Hilb d P 3 is reducible for d " 0. In general, the dimension of Hilb d P 3 is unknown. Basic questions about dimension of tangent spaces to Hilb d P 3 are also wide open. Over forty years ago, Briançon and Iarrobino [BI78] established an upper bound for the dimension of Hilb d P n , and stated two conjectures regarding the largest possible dimension of its tangent spaces.Let k be an arbitrary field. For an ideal I, denote by TpIq the tangent space to the corresponding point rIs in the Hilbert scheme. The question of finding the largest possible dimension of a tangent space to Hilb d P n has been raised in many places, including e.g. [BI78, S00, MS05, AIM10]. To answer this question we restrict to an affine open A n " Spec krx 1 , . . . , x n s Ď P n . It is natural to expect that a fat point subscheme V `px 1 , . . . , x n q r ˘Ď A n yields the...