The recognition of multiple ligands by a single TCR is an intrinsic feature of T cell biology, with important consequences for physiological and pathological processes. Polyspecific T cells targeting distinct self-antigens have been identified in healthy individuals as well as in the context of autoimmunity. We have previously shown that the 2D2 TCR recognizes the myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein epitope (MOG)35–55 as well as an epitope within the axonal protein neurofilament medium (NF-M15–35) in H-2b mice. In this study, we assess whether this cross-reactivity is a common feature of the MOG35–55-specific T cell response. To this end, we analyzed the CD4 T cell response of MOG35–55-immunized C57BL/6 mice for cross-reactivity with NF-M15–35. Using Ag recall responses, we established that an important proportion of MOG35–55-specific CD4 T cells also responded to NF-M15–35 in all mice tested. To study the clonality of this response, we analyzed 22 MOG35–55-specific T cell hybridomas expressing distinct TCR. Seven hybridomas were found to cross-react with NF-M15–35. Using an alanine scan of NF-M18–30 and an in silico predictive model, we dissected the molecular basis of cross-reactivity between MOG35–55 and NF-M15–35. We established that NF-M F24, R26, and V27 proved important TCR contacts. Strikingly, the identified TCR contacts are conserved within MOG38–50. Our data indicate that due to linear sequence homology, part of the MOG35–55-specific T cell repertoire of all C57BL/6 mice also recognizes NF-M15–35, with potential implications for CNS autoimmunity.