Tabletop Board Game Elements and Gamification Interventions for Health Behavior Change: Realist Review and Proposal of a Game Design Framework

Abstract

Background Games, when used as interventional tools, can influence behavior change by incentivizing, reinforcing, educating, providing feedback loops, prompting, persuading, or providing meaning, fun, and community. However, not all game elements will appeal to all consumers equally, and different elements might work for different people and in different contexts. Objective The aim of this study was to conduct a realist review of tabletop games targeting behavior change and to propose a framework for designing effective behavior change games. Methods A realist review was conducted to inform program theory in the development of tabletop games for health behavior change. The context, mechanisms used to change behavior, and outcomes of included studies were reviewed through a realist lens. Results Thirty-one papers met the eligibility criteria and were included in the review. Several design methods were identified that enhanced the efficacy of the games to change behavior. These included design by local teams, pilot testing, clearly defined targets of behavior change, conscious attention to all aspects of game design, including game mechanics, dynamics, aesthetics, and the elicitation of emotions. Delivery with other mediums, leveraging behavioral insights, prior training for delivery, and repeated play were also important. Some design elements that were found to reduce efficacy included limited replayability or lack of fun for immersive engagement. Conclusions Game designers need to consider all aspects of the context and the mechanisms to achieve the desired behavior change outcomes. Careful design thinking should include consideration of the game mechanics, dynamics, aesthetics, emotions, and contexts of the game and the players. People who know the players and the contexts well should design the games or have significant input. Testing in real-world settings is likely to lead to better outcomes. Careful selection and purposeful design of the behavior change mechanisms at play is essential. Fun and enjoyment of the player should be considered, as without engagement, there will be no desired intervention effect.

Nationwide Deployment of a Serious Game Designed to Improve COVID-19 Infection Prevention Practices in Switzerland: Prospective Web-Based Study

“…To disseminate COVID-19 prevention messages in an original and engaging way, a transdepartmental and multidisciplinary development team created Escape COVID-19 [ 24 ], a serious game based on Nicholson’s concept for meaningful gamification [ 25 ]. By increasing the players’ engagement, serious games, which also enhance knowledge, satisfaction, and skills [ 26 ], can help promote adequate behaviors [ 27 , 28 ]. The impact of Escape COVID-19 was assessed in a population of nursing home employees [ 29 ]: In a triple-blind controlled trial, the self-reported likelihood of changing infection prevention and control practices was almost 4 times higher in the group of participants who had followed the serious game [ 29 ].…”

An Exploratory Digital Board Game Approach to the Review and Reinforcement of Complex Medical Subjects Like Anatomical Education: Cross-sectional and Mixed Methods Study

“…The near-universal household penetration of digital games may result in physical play activities, such as board games and other tabletop games, being perceived as old-fashioned [ 24 ]. The digital aspects of such games include advantageous features, such as game analytics or, in the case of education, learning analytics [ 25 , 26 ]; ease of upscaling or mass deployment [ 27 ]; and ease of modification without the need to physically produce new materials [ 27 ].…”

Using the Behaviour Change Wheel Program Planning Model to Design Games for Health: Development Study

“…Its success is largely dependent on eliciting a playful, enjoyable, fun experience while simultaneously delivering efficacious behavior change techniques (BCTs) [ 1 ]. Gs4H seem to effect change in various contexts [ 2 - 5 ]. However, existing studies provide limited guidance for developers interested in designing novel Gs4H.…”