Tactile Materials in Practice: Understanding the Experiences of Teachers of the Visually Impaired

Abstract

Teachers of the visually impaired (TVIs) regularly present tactile materials (tactile graphics, 3D models, and real objects) to students with vision impairments. Researchers have been increasingly interested in designing tools to support the use of tactile materials, but we still lack an in-depth understanding of how tactile materials are created and used in practice today. To address this gap, we conducted interviews with 21 TVIs and a 3-week diary study with eight of them. We found that tactile materials were regularly used for academic as well as non-academic concepts like tactile literacy, motor ability, and spatial awareness. Real objects and 3D models served as “stepping stones” to tactile graphics and our participants preferred to teach with 3D models, despite finding them difficult to create, obtain, and modify. Use of certain materials also carried social implications; participants selected materials that fostered student independence and allow classroom inclusion. We contribute design considerations, encouraging future work on tactile materials to enable student and TVI co-creation, facilitate rapid prototyping, and promote movement and spatial awareness. To support future research in this area, our paper provides a fundamental understanding of current practices. We bridge these practices to established pedagogical approaches and highlight opportunities for growth regarding this important genre of educational materials.

Needs Analysis of Teachers Providing Science Education to Visually Impaired Students and Their Students

“…Developing models in science education for visually impaired students is a crucial step to help them understand and experience scientific concepts. Teachers who possess the skill of material development and dedicate time to it can enhance students' understanding of subjects and increase their participation (Phutane et al, 2022).…”

Designing Conversational Multimodal 3D Printed Models with People who are Blind

“…People who are blind experience difficulty accessing graphical information, particularly educational content [13,48]. 3D printed models are becoming increasingly used as a technology for providing accessible graphics, with widespread interest amongst blind users in how they can be applied in everyday life.…”

Leveraging Robotics to Enhance Accessibility and Engagement in Mathematics Education for Vision-Impaired Students

“…Producing Braille versions of complex mathematical expressions and symbols requires specialized expertise, making it time-consuming [11]. Additionally, learning Braille mathematics notation requires proficiency in tactile perception and accurate interpretation of Braille notations [12]. Another tool used in classrooms is tactile pictures, which pose a challenge due to their limited ability to convey detailed information [7], making it difficult for vision-impaired students to learn the full scope of mathematical concepts.…”