Tailoring a brief intervention for illicit drug use and alcohol use in Irish methadone maintained opiate dependent patients: a qualitative process

Abstract

BackgroundThe World Health Organization (WHO) recommend the tailoring of a brief intervention (BI) programme of research to ensure that it is both culturally and contextually appropriate for the country and the environment in which it is being tested. The majority of BI research has been conducted with non-opioid dependent participants. The current study developed a tailored BI for illicit drug use and alcohol use to a methadone maintained opioid dependent polydrug using cohort of patients.MethodsFocus groups with staff and one-to-one qualitative interviews with patients guided the tailoring of all intervention materials for use in a subsequent cluster randomised controlled trial (RCT). This was done to make them contextually appropriate to an opioid dependent cohort and culturally appropriate to Ireland. Thematic analyses were utilised.ResultsThe BI was modified to ensure its compatibility with the culture of an Irish drug using population, with elements of motivational interviewing (MI) and personalised feedback incorporated. Example scripts of a screening and BI were included, as was an algorithm to facilitate clinicians during a session. Modifications to the ‘Substance Use Risk’ cards included weighting the severity of the problems, writing the language in the first person to personalise the feedback and including tick boxes so as to further highlight the relevant risk factors for individual patients. Photographs of key risk factors were included to display pictorially risks for illiterate or semi-literate patients. Examples of the interaction of particular substances with methadone were of particular importance to this group. Modifications of the ‘Pros and Cons of Substance Use/Reasons to Quit or Cut Down’ included additional categories such as addiction, crime and money that were salient to this cohort. The manual was used to standardise training across trial sites.ConclusionThe research team was faithful to WHO recommendations to tailor BI programmes that are culturally and contextually appropriate to the treatment cohort and clinical environment. Outcome data from the cluster RCT have demonstrated that the tailored intervention was effective.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12888-016-1082-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Systematic content analysis of patient evaluations of START NOW psychotherapy reveals practical strategies for improving the treatment of opioid use disorder

“…Comments from the focus groups also suggest that targeting impulsivity and failure to plan for the future is useful (Table 5 ). Audio-recorded data indicates that patients strongly want psychotherapy vignettes and examples that are culturally-relatable and appropriate (Table 5 ) [ 33 , 34 ]. Furthermore, certain topics—self-care skills and building positive relationships—were very favorably received and thus should be emphasized (Table 5 ) [ 35 ].…”

“…Due to participant preferences or personal disabilities, writing down responses in the workbooks should be optional (Table 5 ). We believe that this may enhance overall participation and engagement [ 33 ]. Participants strongly preferred having their own START NOW workbook to own, personalize, and take home.…”

Developing a brief motivational intervention for young adults admitted with alcohol intoxication in the emergency department – Results from an iterative qualitative design

“… 68 – 71 ], qualitative interviews provided detailed insights regarding the acceptability, feasibility and value of the pretested intervention, while offering information necessary to enhance its components. As noted by Darker, Sweeney [ 71 ], there is a paucity of research that describes the process of tailoring interventions, and using qualitative methods proved to be valuable to identify strengths and necessary modifications to the model before its implementation.…”

Adding quality to quantity in randomized controlled trials of addiction prevention and treatment: a new framework to facilitate the integration of qualitative research

“…The qualitative research sought to ensure that the intervention developed would be culturally and contextually appropriate for Ireland and, more specifically, for a cohort of opioid‐dependent polydrug users. Results highlighted the need for intervention development to be appropriate to both the patient context and the clinical environment, with modifications including the simplification of language, the inclusion of context‐specific examples of criminal activity and the incorporation of pictorial content for patients with low literacy .…”