Tame clients: an evaluation of service users’ and trainee clinical psychologists’ perspective of service user involvement in teaching

Abstract

Purpose The involvement of service users within clinical psychology training is written into policy. However, the practice of evaluating involvement from both trainees’ and service users’ viewpoint is minimal. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate recent service user involvement in psychometrics and formulation teaching on a clinical psychology training programme, from both service user and trainee perspectives. Design/methodology/approach Focus groups were held with service users (n=3) involved in the teaching, as well as trainees (n=3). Additional questionnaire data were captured from trainees (n=11). Service user and trainee data were analysed separately using thematic analysis. Themes generated for trainees were also mapped on to a competency framework for clinical psychologists. Findings Both parties found the teaching beneficial. Service users enjoyed supporting trainees and engaged positively in their roles. They identified relational aspects and reflections on their own therapy as other benefits. Trainees reported enhanced clinical preparedness, critical and personal reflection. Trainee anxiety was evident. Learning mapped well to competency frameworks. Research limitations/implications The samples were small and some data truncated. Findings speak to broader issues and may transfer to other involvement contexts. Practical implications A good degree of meaningful involvement can be achieved through such initiatives, to mutual benefit and enhanced learning. Originality/value Nature of the exercise and dual-aspect approach to evaluation described here helps to minimise tokenism. The mapping of findings to competency frameworks supports evaluative processes and helps to legitimise involvement initiatives that challenge the boundaries of existing practice.

They are a different breed aren’t they? Exploring how experts by experience influence students through mental health education

“…Allies observed students becoming more reflective due to EBE involvement in teaching. Reflective and critical approaches are essential for recovery‐oriented practice (Happell et al., 2019c) and have been identified in previous research as a significant benefit of EBE teaching (Happell et al., 2019c; Norwood et al., 2019; Wilson, 2019).…”

Exploring trainee perspectives on barriers and facilitators in serious mental illness doctoral training.

“…Indeed, there is research to suggest that ad hoc interventions targeting education and experience with SMI populations successfully reduced biases towards SMI populations (Brown et al, 2010; Lincoln et al, 2008; Mann & Himelein, 2008; Read & Law, 1999), and greater knowledge of recovery and recovery models may reduce stigma (O’Connor, 2021). Further, involvement of people with lived experience of SMI in the training of clinical psychologists is written into policy in other countries and has important effects on stigma and competence (e.g., Clarke & Holttum, 2013; Hayward et al, 2005; Norwood et al, 2019).…”