“…37 The generation of T SCM -like T cells in the presence of IL-21 has been described before. 38,39 As opposed to the results of Cieri et al, Chen and colleagues, who compared differentiation of T N to T SCM in the presence of IL-2, IL-7, IL-15 or IL-21 after aCD3/CD28 activation, showed that IL-21 has the highest potential to induce T SCM , 40 which is in line with our observations. Discrepancies in T SCM phenotype indicate differences between T SCM -like cells generated in vitro from HSPC in OP9-DL1 co-cultures (and subsequent agonist selection with the cognate peptide in the presence of cytokine(s), as compared to T SCM -like cells as generated in vitro starting from T N by Cieri et al and Chen et al (by activating T N with aCD3/aCD28 in the presence of cytokine(s)), and T SCM cells as isolated directly from healthy donors by Gattinoni et al 14,15,40 In their report, Vizcardo et al state that CD8 + SP T cells generated in OP9-DL1 co-cultures are 'abnormal', with high expression of NK cell markers, indicating innate-like features, and upregulation of PTCRA, RAG1, RAG2 and RORC, indicating an immature phenotype.…”