Graves’ hyperthyroidism, a common autoimmune disease caused by pathogenic autoantibodies to the thyrotropin (TSH) receptor, can be treated but not cured. This single autoantigenic target makes Graves’ disease a prime candidate for antigen-specific immunotherapy. Previously, in an induced mouse model, injecting TSHR A-subunit protein attenuated hyperthyroidism by diverting pathogenic TSHR antibodies to a non-functional variety. Here we explored the possibility of a similar diversion in a mouse model that spontaneously develops pathogenic TSHR autoantibodies, NOD.H2h4 mice with the human(h) TSHR A-subunit transgene expressed in the thyroid and (shown here) the thymus. We hypothesized that such diversion would occur following injection of “inactive” hTSHR A-subunit protein recognized only by non-pathogenic (not pathogenic) TSHR antibodies. Surprisingly, rather than attenuating the pre-existing pathogenic TSHR level, in TSHR/NOD.H2h4 mice inactive hTSHR antigen injected without adjuvant enhanced the levels of pathogenic TSH-binding inhibition (TBI) and thyroid stimulating antibodies, as well as non-pathogenic antibodies detected by ELISA. This effect was TSHR-specific as spontaneously occurring autoantibodies to thyroglobulin and thyroid peroxidase were unaffected. As controls, non-transgenic NOD.H2h4 mice similarly injected with inactive hTSHR A-subunit protein unexpectedly developed TSHR antibodies, but only of the non-pathogenic variety detected by ELISA. Our observations highlight critical differences between induced and spontaneous mouse models of Graves’ disease with implications for potential immunotherapy in humans. In hTSHR/NOD.H2h4 mice with ongoing disease, injecting inactive hTSHR A-subunit protein fails to divert the autoantibody response to a non-pathogenic form. Indeed, such therapy is likely to enhance pathogenic antibody production and exacerbate Graves’ disease in humans.