Task-based assessment of digital mammography microcalcification detection with deep learning denoising algorithms using in silico and physical phantom studies

Abstract

Recent research suggests that image quality degradation with reduced radiation exposure in mammography can be mitigated by postprocessing mammograms with denoising algorithms based on convolutional neural networks. Breast microcalcifications, along with extended soft-tissue lesions, are the primary breast cancer biomarkers in a clinical x-ray examination, with the former being more sensitive to quantum noise. We test one such publicly available denoising method to observe if an improvement in detection of small microcalcifications can be achieved when deep learning-based denoising is applied to half-dose phantom scans.Approach: An existing denoiser model (that was previously trained on clinical data) was applied to mammograms of an anthropomorphic physical phantom with hydroxyapatite microcalcifications. In addition, another model trained and tested using all synthetic (Monte Carlo) data was applied to a similar digital compressed breast phantom. Human reader studies were conducted to assess and compare image quality in a set of binary signal detection 4-AFC experiments, with proportion of correct responses used as a performance metric. Results:In both physical phantom/clinical system and simulation studies, we saw no apparent improvement in small microcalcification signal detection in denoised half-dose mammograms. However, in a Monte Carlo study, we observed a noticeable jump in 4-AFC scores, when readers analyzed denoised half-dose images processed by the neural network trained on a dataset composed of 50% signalpresent (SP) and 50% signal-absent regions of interest (ROIs).Conclusions: Our findings conjecture that deep-learning denoising algorithms may benefit from enriching training datasets with SP ROIs, at least in cases with clusters of 5 to 10 microcalcifications, each of size ≲240 μm.