Task-Based Effectiveness of Interactive Contiguous Area Cartograms

Abstract

Cartograms are map-based data visualizations in which the area of each map region is proportional to an associated numeric data value (e.g., population or gross domestic product). A cartogram is called contiguous if it conforms to this area principle while also keeping neighboring regions connected. Because of their distorted appearance, contiguous cartograms have been criticized as difficult to read. Some authors have suggested that cartograms may be more legible if they are accompanied by interactive features (e.g., animations, linked brushing, or infotips). We conducted an experiment to evaluate this claim. Participants had to perform visual analysis tasks with interactive and noninteractive contiguous cartograms. The task types covered various aspects of cartogram readability, ranging from elementary lookup tasks to synoptic tasks (i.e., tasks in which participants had to summarize high-level differences between two cartograms). Elementary tasks were carried out equally well with and without interactivity. Synoptic tasks, by contrast, were more difficult without interactive features. With access to interactivity, however, most participants answered even synoptic questions correctly. In a subsequent survey, participants rated the interactive features as "easy to use" and "helpful." Our study suggests that interactivity has the potential to make contiguous cartograms accessible even for those readers who are unfamiliar with interactive computer graphics or do not have a prior affinity to working with maps. Among the interactive features, animations had the strongest positive effect, so we recommend them as a minimum of interactivity when contiguous cartograms are displayed on a computer screen.

OctoPocus in VR: Using a Dynamic Guide for 3D Mid-Air Gestures in Virtual Reality

“…Wilcoxon Signed Rank tests were used to analyze subjective ratings. Similar to [54], we also report 95% confidence intervals as [low, high] for the difference of means to minimize the over-interpretation of p-values [55].…”

Multicriteria Optimization for Dynamic Demers Cartograms

“…For example, leaders are drawn or highlighted for a selected region, to allow seeing the topological adjacencies immediately in the cartogram. Of course, such interactions can be complemented by juxtaposing it with a linked view that shows the geographic map in which the same regions can be highlighted, which was shown to be effective even for novice users at least for contiguous area cartograms [40].…”

Effectiveness of Area-to-Value Legends and Grid Lines in Contiguous Area Cartograms

“…An early study conducted in 1999 by Peterson [19] explored the potential of computer technology by developing an interactive legend that controlled a cartographic animation using JavaScript. In a more recent study, Duncan et al [20] experimentally evaluated whether cartograms can convey information more effectively with three additional interactive features: cartogram-switching animations, linked brushing, and infotips. These features were also implemented using JavaScript and are currently deployed on the web application go-cart.io [21], [22].…”

“…We used the ColorBrewer palette Dark2 with six colors [25] and ensured that distinct colors were used for neighboring regions. We also implemented a linked-brushing effect, whereby the color of an administrative unit changed its brightness on both maps when the participant hovered the pointer over the unit on one of the maps [20]. The choice of colors and the linked brushing effect were intended to make it easier for participants to locate an administrative unit on all maps shown during a task [2].…”

“…In web-based cartograms, it is possible to include more interactive features than those investigated in the present study. For example, an infotip [20] (i.e., a text box with information about the region at the position of the mouse pointer) serves a similar purpose as legends and grid lines; that is, it allows participants to infer the magnitude of the numerical data value that is represented by a region in a cartogram. As illustrated in Fig.…”