“…There were studies has shown that independent commissioners negatively affect tax avoidance (Maharani & Suardana, 2014;Santoso & Muid, 2014;Diantari & Ulupui, 2016;Lutfia & Pratomo, 2018;Gunawan et al, 2021). Meanwhile, the opposite study has shown that independent commissioners do not affect tax avoidance (Dewi & Jati, 2014;Puspita & Harto, 2014;Pradipta & Supriyadi, 2015;Mappadang, 2021;Lismiyati & Herliansyah, 2021;Apriyanti & Arifin, 2021;Sahrir et al, 2021). There were the studies that resulted in the audit committee having a positive effect on tax avoidance (Dewi & Jati, 2014;Idzniah & Bernawati, 2020;Sunarto et al, 2021), while the other studies have shown that the audit committee has a negative effect on tax avoidance (Maharani & Suardana, 2014, Diantari & Ulupui, 2016, and Apriyanti & Arifin, 2021.…”