“…We also used the comment and reply feature in the interactive journal space to begin to raise themes we noticed regarding how issues related to class, race, gender, religion, heteronormativity—and the intertwining of these—all were important dimensions of our identities that interfaced with our perceived legitimacy, our pedagogical decision making, and the ways in which we presented and shared ourselves and our stories in professional settings. Drawing also upon a review of the self‐study literature that identified three major facets that shape teacher educator identity, we considered how our personal and professional biographies, our contexts, and our personal pedagogies of teacher education (Newberry, ; Williams, Ritter, & Bullock, ) shape our professional and social identities as teacher educators. We used these dimensions from the literature as well as the themes we identified in our interactive journal space to more deeply explore our responses to the two prompts in our narratives and our journaling, ultimately grouping themes related to the intertwining of our social and professional identities and our pedagogies, and the impact of multiple contexts on our identities and pedagogies, which we explore below.…”