Teachers’ and Learners’ Experiences of Entrepreneurial Education: Practice and Challenges in Relation to Visible and Invisible Pedagogy

Abstract

Entrepreneurial education is described as gaining abilities that enable the future workforce to develop, be part of and adapt to the changing society. International policy texts, from for instance the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the European Commission, agree that entrepreneurial abilities are to be taught and learned in school. Even if this has been on the agenda for decades, it wasn’t inscribed in the Swedish curricula until 2011. This research focuses on lower secondary schools and what is called the broad approach or entrepreneurial education. To foster entrepreneurially, different progressive theories of instruction are often suggested. Basil Bernstein has outlined two generic forms of instructional theories: visible and invisible pedagogy; visible pedagogy can be described as “traditional”, while invisible pedagogy requires progressive teaching and learning. Based on classroom observations, interviews with teachers and learners, this study elaborates on these concepts in relation to experiences of entrepreneurial education. Different challenges, due to contradictory messages in curricula, learners’ backgrounds and experiences, as well as teachers’ approaches, are revealed. The study suggests that, even though more or less ambitious attempts are being made, “pure” entrepreneurial education is difficult to enable in a practice where visible pedagogy is the standard educational practice. Key words: entrepreneurial education, lower secondary school, teachers’ and learners’ experiences, parental background, visible and invisible pedagogy.

A Review from the Malaysian Perspective on Factors Influencing Sustainable Entrepreneurship in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises ((SMEs)

“…When coping with uncertain business conditions, SME owners should lead with vision, passion, integrity, and confidence (Yadegaridehkordi et al, 2023). The SMEs owners, operators and managers should have the capability to give instructions and can have a well communication with everyone (Diehl, 2016). An enterprise can achieve sustainability under three situations including the leadership position and the proper market.…”

“…Networks in the firms in SMEs can bring sustainability to the firm. For example, here are the tourism networks in Finland, YSMEK-Network for Developing Environmentally Friendlier Tourism (Diehl, 2016). The Finnish Tourist Board YSMEK established the network in 1993 and plays the role to introduce sustainability to the Finnish tourism enterprises.…”

“…Small and medium-sized business research states confidently that internal organizational factors and external forces give effect to the SMEs business performance due to the minimum boundary of the customers' orientation. Customer orientation is the main reason SMEs has a deficiency of the long rank of attention in strategic orientation and proper decision-making (Diehl, 2016).…”

Entrepreneurial Learning: Creating Value towards Social Justice

“…Constructivism, and especially socio-constructivism, is frequently used as a framework for entrepreneurship education and entrepreneurial learning (Brown, 2018;Daniel, 2016;Diehl, 2016;Du Toit & Kempen, 2018;Grigg, 2021;Löbler, 2006;Rae, 2011;Verzat et al, 2016). According to Verzat et al (2016), constructivist learning contributes to learners' personal (individual) development but can often lead to positive societal changes.…”

“…Entrepreneurship education is a strategic topic in educational curricula that contributes to attaining social justice through economic equality. This is one of the main reasons why many school curricula across the globe include entrepreneurship education (Aransyah et al, 2023;Barba-Sánchez & Atienza-Sahuquillo, 2016;Diehl, 2016;Sekerbayeva et al, 2023).…”