Telescoping of caregiver report on the Autism Diagnostic Interview - Revised

Abstract

Background Delays in development are a fundamental feature in diagnosing autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Age of language acquisition, usually obtained through retrospective caregiver report, is currently used to distinguish between categories within ASD. Research has shown that caregivers often report children as having acquired developmental milestones earlier or later than they were actually achieved. The current study examines the extent to which this phenomenon, referred to as ‘telescoping,’ impacts retrospective reports provided by caregivers of children with ASD. Methods Participants were 127 caregivers of children referred for possible ASD or non-spectrum developmental delay. Caregivers were interviewed when children were 2, 3, 5, and 9 years of age. Caregiver-reported ages of first concern, language and non-diagnostic developmental milestones and interviewer-estimated age of onset were compared over time using linear models. Results Significant telescoping of language milestones resulted in more children meeting language delay criteria as they grew older, in spite of original reports that their language was not delayed. There was little evidence of consistent telescoping of caregiver-reported ages of first concern, daytime bladder control, and independent walking. With time, the interviewers’ judged ages of symptom onset increased, but remained prior to age three. Conclusions Telescoping of caregiver-reported ages of language acquisition has implications for both clinical diagnosis and genetic studies using these milestones to increase homogeneity of samples. Results support proposals to remove specific age-based criteria in the diagnosis of ASD. Telescoping should be considered when working with any clinical population in which retrospectively recalled events are used in diagnosis.

Age of First Words Predicts Cognitive Ability and Adaptive Skills in Children with ASD

“…This information was obtained from the caregiver during a clinical interview using the ADI-R. Following ADI-R administration protocol, parents were asked to give examples of first words; follow up questions helped clarify that words were used meaningfully, a process which has been found to promote more accurate parent recall (Hus et al 2011). …”

Who's Missing the Point? A Commentary on Claims that Autistic Persons Have a Specific Deficit in Figurative Language Comprehension

“…But Asperger diagnoses are notoriously unreliable indicants of early language development (Lord et al, 2011); parents, whose retrospective memory often determines Asperger diagnoses, are notoriously unreliable informants of early language acquisition (Hus, Taylor, & Lord, 2011), and Asperger diagnoses are notoriously unreliable indexes of current-day language comprehension ability (Bennett et al, 2008; Lewis, Murdoch, & Woodyatt, 2007).…”

Brief Report: Investigating the Implications of Applying the New DSM-5 Criteria for Diagnosing Autism Spectrum Disorder in a Preschool Population in Singapore

“…The duration and intensity of some possible RRB were described as very mild at the time of interview, and not causing significant enough impairment. Parents have been described to provide accurate estimates of their child's current development, but their ability to recall past developmental milestones is unreliable (Hus et al 2011).…”