Temporal Distributions of Problem Behavior Based on Scatter Plot Analysis

Abstract

The scatter plot is a commonly used assessment tool for identifying temporal patterns in the occurrence of behavior problems. However, the extent to which such patterns are frequently observed is unknown because little research has evaluated the general utility of the scatter plot. We conducted a large-scale analysis of within-and across-day occurrences of problem behavior by conducting continuous observations of 20 individuals living in four residential facilities. Data were recorded during 30-min intervals throughout participants' waking hours for 30 days by direct care staff and were converted into scatter plot formats. Five sets of data were excluded from further analysis due to poor interobserver agreement (below 80%). Visual analysis of the remaining 15 scatter plots indicated that none showed any reliable temporal pattern of responding. However, when the data were transformed into aggregate ''control charts'' based on statistical process control procedures, 12 of the 15 sets of data revealed one or more 30-min intervals during which problem behavior was more likely to occur. Results are discussed in terms of the practicality of applying statistical analyses to scatter plot data and of collecting data for the length of time needed to show statistical significance. It was concluded that detailed functional or descriptive analyses, which would reveal cause-effect or correlational relationships between behavior and specific environmental events, may be both more precise and more efficient forms of assessment.DESCRIPTORS: behavior problems, behavioral assessment, descriptive analysis, observation procedures, scatter plot, statistical process controlResearch on the treatment of severe behavior disorders conducted over the past 15 years has focused greater attention on the

On the Representativeness of Behavior Observation Samples in Classrooms

“…To the extent that problem behavior occurs according to a regular schedule (or more accurately is correlated with events that change in a routine classroom schedule), one may be more likely to capture an accurate estimation of behavior by setting a regular observation schedule than by randomly sampling during the day (or less likely if the scheduled time coincides with highpreference activities). We examined our data and failed to identify temporal patterns of problem behavior across the 4 days (similar to the data presented in Panels G and H of Figure 4 that depict the first and last sessions, respectively, collected for Tina's spinning each day; see also Kahng et al, 1998). Future research may determine whether teacher-nominated observation periods are more representative or more likely to capture problem behavior than randomly or conveniently determined observation periods.…”

Using ABC narrative recording to identify the function of problem behavior: A pilot study

“…However, in a study with 20 participants diagnosed with an intellectual disability, Kahng et al (1998) found that the scatterplot produced poor agreement between observers for 5 participants and failed to detect temporal patterns in the ABC NARRATIVE RECORDING 6 remaining 15 participants. Thus, empirical support for the scatterplot is currently insufficient (Matson & Minshawi, 2007).…”

Different Methods for Long-term Systematic Assessment of Challenging Behaviors in People with Severe Intellectual Disability

“…With these video files we can check behaviors in a systematic and exhaustive way, rigorously examine the frequency, duration and intensity of each selected behavior, facilitating data entry, offering the possibility of issuing reports and statistical charts quickly. This tool was selected because it offers the possibility to comprehensively analyze as often as necessary video files, and be used for live observation (Kahng et al, 1998). …”