“…Furthermore, some of the lithofacies that dominate this interval, and the interpreted depositional environments, are very similar to those described from the Waterford Formation of the Ecca Group by Rubidge et al (2000) and Mason et al (2015) from the south-western and south-eastern main Karoo Basin, respectively. In particular, Rubidge's (1988) Facies A and E, which are considered to be most diagnostic of the Waterford Formation further south in the basin (Rubidge et al, 2000(Rubidge et al, , 2012Mason, 2007;Mason et al, 2015), correspond directly with Lithofacies types R and Sd, respectively. Based on lithologic and genetic similarities, we consider the stratigraphic interval where FA2, FA3, and FA4 occur to be lithologically equivalent to the Waterford Formation, which forms the uppermost stratigraphic unit of the Ecca Group in the south of the main Karoo Basin, and these rocks should thus be included within the Ecca rather than the Beaufort Group.…”