Test-Retest Reliability of the Timed Up and Go Test in Subjects with Parkinson’s Disease: Implications for Longitudinal Assessments

Abstract

Background: Despite the frequent use of the Timed Up and Go (TUG) test in clinical trials, evaluation of longitudinal test-retest reliability is generally lacking and still inconclusive for patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD). Objective: We aimed to further investigate long-term reliability and sensitivity of the TUG test among this population. Furthermore, we explored alternative assessment strategies of the test aimed at elucidating whether the inclusion or combination of timed trials may have potential implications on outcome measure. Methods: Relative and absolute reliability of the TUG performance were obtained in forty-three subjects with PD over three timed trials in two different testing sessions separated by a two-months period. Results: Our results reported excellent intra-session and moderate inter-session reliability coefficients. The use of different assessment strategies of the TUG was found to have an important impact on outcome measure, highlighting the averaging of several timed trials in each testing session as a recommended alternative to minimize measurement error and increase reliability in longitudinal assessments. Nevertheless, beyond acceptable reliability, poor trial-to-trial stability of the measure appears to exist, since the ranges of expected variability upon retesting were wide and the incidence of spurious statistical effects was not negligible, especially in longitudinal repeated testing. Conclusion: Limitations may exist in the interpretation of the TUG outputs as part of longitudinal assessments aimed at evaluating treatment effectiveness in PD population. Researchers and practitioners should be aware of these concerns to prevent possible misrepresentations of functional ability in patients for a particular intervention.

Effects of Biodanza® SRT on Motor, Cognitive, and Behavioral Symptoms in Patients with Parkinson’s Disease: A Randomized Controlled Study

“…Furthermore, we observed a significant reduction in TUG scores only within the Biodanza group compared to the baseline assessment, with repercussions in terms of greater postural stability and a reduction in the risk of falling. The improvements recorded in TUG times at the end of active treatment have been reported also in previous studies that adopted other types of dance therapy, despite this measure seems to be less sensitive to the intervention effects than the other measures of functional mobility [ 28 , 49 , 50 ]. Hackney and Earhart also demonstrated that complex tango steps produced improvement effects in terms of balance and postural stability [ 51 ].…”

A Pilot Study of the Effects of Individualized Home Dual Task Training by Mobile Health Technology in People with Dementia

“…The Timed Up and Go (TUG) test [ 35 ] is a useful tool to assess gait-related functioning and motor symptoms because it involves sequential locomotor tasks that incorporate walking and turning, which are both affected by cognitive impairment [ 36 , 37 ]. In the assessment protocol, patients were seated on a chair, and were instructed to stand up, walk at their own comfortable and safe walking speed for 3 m, turn 180◦ at a designated spot, come back, and sit down on the chair again.…”

A Step Forward Understanding Directional Limitations in Markerless Smartphone-Based Gait Analysis: A Pilot Study

“…This test was initially developed by Podsiadlo and Richardson in 1991 [1] in the original version of the test named the "Get-up and Go", which aimed to evaluate dynamic balance in elderly people [2]. This test was further successfully tested on patients with multiple disorders [3][4][5]. The TUG test highly correlates with age, socioeconomic status, and multiple comorbidities [6].…”