Testing Convergence Using HAR Inference

Abstract

Measurement of diminishing or divergent cross section dispersion in a panel plays an important role in the assessment of convergence or divergence over time in key economic indicators. Econometric methods, known as weak -convergence tests, have recently been developed (Kong et al., 2019)) to evaluate such trends in dispersion in panel data using simple linear trend regressions. To achieve generality in applications, these tests rely on heteroskedastic and autocorrelation consistent (HAC) variance estimates. The present paper examines the behavior of these convergence tests when heteroskedastic and autocorrelation robust (HAR) variance estimates using …xed-b methods are employed instead of HAC estimates. Asymptotic theory for both HAC and HAR convergence tests is derived and numerical simulations are used to assess performance in null (no convergence) and alternative (convergence) cases. While the use of HAR statistics tends to reduce size distortion, as has been found in earlier analytic and numerical research, use of HAR estimates in nonparametric standardization leads to signi…cant power di¤erences asymptotically, which are re ‡ected in …nite sample performance in numerical exercises. The explanation is that weak -convergence tests rely on intentionally misspeci…ed linear trend regression formulations of unknown trend decay functions that model convergence behavior rather than regressions with correctly speci-…ed trend decay functions. Some new results on the use of HAR inference with trending regressors are derived and an empirical application to assess diminishing variation in US State unemployment rates is included.