‘That red flag on your file’: misinterpreting physical symptoms as mental illness

Abstract

Aims and objectives To ascertain the views and experiences of mental health consumers regarding the availability and quality of care and treatment received for their physical health needs. Background People diagnosed with mental illness have higher occurrence of physical health problems. Responsive health care services are crucial for prevention and management of physical health problems, and for reducing disparities in health between people diagnosed with mental illness and those who are not. There is limited research giving voice to consumer perspectives on their experiences with health care providers. Design Exploratory qualitative. Methods Focus group interviews with mental health consumers accessed via a consumer network group in a region of Australia (n = 31). All interview audio recordings were transcribed professionally. Interviews were thematically analysed. Results The main themes were: symptomising; failure to act and alertness to prejudice. The first two themes were consumer perceptions of the actions and behaviours of health professionals, and the third describes consumer responses to these behaviours and actions. Consumers described increased risks of illness and death because of undiagnosed physical illness despite their physical health advice‐seeking as the reason for the health consultation. Conclusion Health care providers’ non‐recognition of physical health problems presents a clear example of a significant and potentially life threatening health inequity. The service provider responses described by participants suggest that mental health consumers’ physical health needs may not be taken seriously. Relevance to clinical practice Clinicians need to take seriously the physical health needs and concerns of people with mental illness. Nurses can play a crucial role in the prevention of diagnostic overshadowing as part of a broader direction of balancing biomedical perspectives with other approaches to health care.

Stage at diagnosis and survival in patients with cancer and a pre-existing mental illness: a meta-analysis

“…We hypothesise that differences in cancer care delivery from the point of diagnosis may explain the higher risk of death and may be a modifiable means of improving outcomes 20 24 54. However, our findings on stage were less robust and other aspects of the cancer control spectrum may be involved.…”

“…Disparities may be related to contraindications to care resulting from coexisting physical comorbidities, drug interactions with chemotherapy or perceived inability to adhere to strict treatment protocols. Disparities in cancer care may arise from social vulnerability factors such as low income or homelessness or through fragmented healthcare delivery, stigma and bias that create barriers to accessing or receiving patientcentred care 21–26…”

Enabling healthy living: Experiences of people with severe mental illness in psychiatric outpatient services

“…Poor physical health among people with SMI requires both greater knowledge and training among health care professionals (Happell et al . ). Furthermore, the administrators of the mental health services and the municipalities have a crucial role in implementing policies to increase possibilities for achieving healthy living among people with SMI (Happell et al .…”

“…Furthermore, the attitude and unsuitable approach of professionals towards people with SMI, who may also have symptoms of physical illness have been highlighted as a serious issue that increases health inequalities (Happell et al . ). People with SMI are often interested in increasing their knowledge about healthy living and learning more about how to improve their health (Verhaeghe et al .…”

Supporting patients with serious mental illness during physical health treatment

“…At discharge, Patricia believed that the treating team had failed to vigorously investigate her physical symptoms because of her mental health condition; a belief that has been reported elsewhere by people with SMI when accessing general healthcare (Nash 2014). In one study, a patient described having SMI as a 'red flag on your file' that invalidated their physical health concern (Happell et al 2016). Ross and Goldner (2009) conducted a literature review into the stigmatisation of people with SMI in healthcare, reporting that the physical health concerns of patients with SMI were frequently given little credibility, with assumptions made by staff that the physical health concerns reported by this group were symptoms of their mental health conditions.…”