“…We read with great interest the comments by the posse of professors from around the world led by McAllister-Williams and were suitably gratified by the positive endorsement of our recently published mood disorders guidelines (MDcpg 2020 ; Malhi et al, 2021), which incidentally are also available as summaries (Malhi et al, 2020a, 2020b). We were heartened for example by their pleasing comment regarding the content of the MDcpg 2020 that ‘ there is much of value, certainly regarding medications ’ (McAllister-Williams et al, 2021), but were somewhat at a loss as to why they had stopped short of descriptions used by others such as ‘intellectually dazzling’ (Rosenman, 2021).…”