The cell painting (CP) assay has emerged as a potent imaging-based high-throughput phenotypic profiling (HTPP) tool that provides comprehensive input data for in silico prediction of compound activities and potential hazards in drug discovery and toxicology. CP enables the rapid, multiplexed investigation of various molecular mechanisms for thousands of compounds at the single-cell level. The resulting large volumes of image data provide great opportunities but also pose challenges to image and data analysis routines as well as property prediction models. This review addresses the integration of CP-based phenotypic data together with or in substitute of structural information from compounds into machine (ML) and deep learning (DL) models to predict compound activities for various human-relevant disease endpoints and to identify the underlying modes-of-action (MoA) while avoiding unnecessary animal testing. The successful application of CP in combination with powerful ML/DL models promises further advances in understanding compound responses of cells guiding therapeutic development and risk assessment. Therefore, this review highlights the importance of unlocking the potential of CP assays when combined with molecular fingerprints for compound evaluation and discusses the current challenges that are associated with this approach.