The art of being healthy: a qualitative study to develop a thematic framework for understanding the relationship between health and the arts

Abstract

ObjectiveIn recent years the health–arts nexus has received increasing attention; however, the relationship is not well understood and the extent of possible positive, negative and unintended outcomes is unknown. Guided by the biopsychosocial model of health and theories of social epidemiology, the aim of this study was to develop a framework pertaining to the relationship between arts engagement and population health that included outcomes, confounders and effect modifiers. A health–arts framework is of value to researchers seeking to build the evidence base; health professionals interested in understanding the health–arts relationship, especially those who use social prescribing for health promotion or to complement treatments; in teaching medical, nursing and health-science students about arts outcomes, as well as artists and health professionals in the development of policy and programmes.DesignA qualitative study was conducted. Semistructured interviews were analysed thematically.SettingWestern Australia.Participants33 Western Australian adults (18+ years). Participants were randomly selected from a pool of general population nominees who engaged in the arts for enjoyment, entertainment or as a hobby (response rate=100%).ResultsA thematic analysis was conducted using QSR-NVivo10. The resulting framework contained seven outcome themes and 63 subthemes. Three themes specifically related to health, that is, mental, social and physical health, while economic, knowledge, art and identity outcomes were classified as health determinants. Within each theme, positive, negative and unintended outcomes (subthemes) were identified and categorised as relating to the individual and/or to the community. A list of confounding and/or effect modifying factors, related to both the arts and health, was identified.ConclusionsGiven the increasing pressure on health resources, the arts have the potential to assist in the promotion of health and healing. This framework expands on current knowledge, further defines the health–arts relationship and is a step towards the conceptualisation of a causal health–arts model.

"You Can't Feel Healthier than Your Caregiver" - The Ripple Effect of Trust and Empathy for Patients and Health Care Staff, Cultivated through Cultural Activities

“…One way of understanding and working with the complexity of a medical intervention (such as arts in health) is to continue collecting and analysing qualitative data together with the quantitative data such as that gathered in this Palette project [14]. Another way is to draw on theoretical frameworks in order to understand the relationships of the setting in question with a view to developing research within arts and health in future project planning [31,32].…”

“Building strength in coming together”: A mixed methods study using the arts to explore smoking with staff working in Indigenous tobacco control

“…A health–arts framework has been found to be of value to researchers to build an evidence base: for health professionals interested in understanding the health–arts relationship. It is especially useful for those who use health promotion, in teaching health professionals, and for artists and health professionals in the development of policy and programs …”

“…It is especially useful for those who use health promotion, in teaching health professionals, and for artists and health professionals in the development of policy and programs. [2][3][4][5] Indigenous participation in arts activities is relatively high, and was reported as 31% by Arts Victoria, Australia. 6 Participation in arts activities can be a protective factor against substance abuse and self-harm for Indigenous peoples.…”

The Road to Resilience: Traveling the Path Less Followed to Realize What is Possible

“…There is a growing body of evidence to support the relationship between art-based interventions and health outcomes (Davies, Knuiman, Wright, & Rosenberg, 2014;Stuckey & Nobel, 2010). Research by Davies, Knuiman, and Rosenberg (2016) found evidence of an expressive arts and mental health relationship.…”