The Assessment and Non-Pharmacologic Treatment of Procedural Pain From Infancy to School Age Through a Developmental Lens: A Synthesis of Evidence With Recommendations

Abstract

Introduction The 2011 IOM report stated that pain management in children is often lacking especially during routine medical procedures. The purpose of this review is to bring a developmental lens to the challenges in assessment and non-pharmacologic treatment of pain in young children. Method A synthesis of the findings from an electronic search of PubMed and the university library using the keywords pain, assessment, treatment, alternative, complementary, integrative, infant, toddler, preschool, young, pediatric, and child was completed. A targeted search identified additional sources for best evidence. Results Assessment of developmental cues is essential. For example, crying, facial expression, and body posture are behaviors in infancy that indicate pain: However in toddlers these same behaviors are not necessarily indicative of pain. Preschoolers need observation scales in combination with self-report while for older children self-report is the gold standard. Pain management in infants includes swaddling and sucking. However for toddlers, preschoolers and older children, increasingly sophisticated distraction techniques such as easily implemented non-pharmacologic pain management strategies include reading stories, watching cartoons, or listening to music. Discussion A developmental approach to assessing and treating pain is critical. Swaddling, picture books, or blowing bubbles are easy and effective when used at the appropriate developmental stage and relieve both physical and emotional pain. Untreated pain in infants and young children may lead to increased pain perception and chronic pain in adolescents and adults. Continued research in the non-pharmacological treatment of pain is an important part of the national agenda.

Comparison of iatrogenic pain between rotavirus vaccination before and after vaccine injection in 2-month-old infants

“…We used 5 major indices that parents are concerned with to measure pain response. These factors have been widely recognized as nonverbal pain indicators 5 . We analyzed these factors separately to prevent potential variations in a single index 9 .…”

“…For each infant, the minimal and maximal grades of each pain category were 0 and 2, respectively. The pain scale used in this study was modified from published assessment tools, including the CRIES observational assessment tool and the FLACC measurement tool 5 . A well-trained nurse performed the standardized observational pain scale measurements.…”

“…Pain during infancy can have long-term effects on physiologic and behavioral responses to vaccination 5 . Moreover, parents may be reluctant to vaccination because of its adverse effects 6,7 .…”

Non - Pharmacological Pain Management in Postoperative Care of School - Age Children

“…Researches have been performed in Finland and other European and World countries by He et al (2010), Svendsen & Bjørk (2014), Thrane et al (2016) showing that non-pharmacological methods are used and they are effective methods for relieving pediatric pain [2;7;8].…”

Pain Control and Parent Mental Health Among Pediatric Inpatients

“…1 During hospitalization, more than half of children experience moderate to severe pain. 2,3 Inadequate pain control is a problem for a large proportion of these children, up to 10% of whom have pain that remains high despite interventions. 4,5 In recent years, the wide dissemination of accurate visual analog and behavioral observation scales has improved the assessment of pain in children.…”