Despite growing interest in doctors’ use of social media, little is known about how medical professionals want to appear before online audiences. This multi-method qualitative study fills this gap by analyzing the self-presentation of 12 Egyptian medical doctors who create health-related video content (vlogs) on social media. We pair in-depth interview and focus groups data with a critical discourse analysis of 48 vlogs to investigate how these physicians construct their images as both health professionals (doctors) and content makers (influencers). In doing so, we rely on Goffman’s dramaturgical approach to examine the “faces” they wear in their vlogs and the strategies they used to manage when and how each face is perceived. We find that participants presented themselves through four faces: Approachable, Knowledgeable, Pedagogical, and Popular. Their self-presentation appears to be a negotiation between two roles: part doctor, or health service provider, and part influencer, or social media content creator.