Methacholine challenge in preschool children: methacholine-induced wheeze versus transcutaneous oximetry. S.C. Yong, C.M. Smith, R. Wach, M. Kurian, R.A. Primhak. # ERS Journals Ltd 1999. ABSTRACT: Tracheal/chest auscultation for wheeze and transcutaneous oximetry have both been suggested as measures of outcome in bronchial provocation tests in young children. This study aimed to compare the sensitivity and safety of these two techniques as end-points for methacholine challenge in children aged <4 yrs.Seventy-two methacholine challenges were performed in 39 children aged <4 yrs with recurrent wheeze. Arterial oxygen saturation (Sa,O 2 ) and transcutaneous oxygen pressure tcPO 2 continuously, and the test was terminated when wheeze was heard or at Sa,O 2 <91%. tcPO 2 was not used as an end-point.Wheeze or desaturation occurred at #8 mg . mL -1 methacholine in every test. One child had transient clinical cyanosis, but no other ill-effects were seen. Fifty-six tests (78%) were terminated for wheeze, seven (10%) for fall in Sa,O 2 and nine (12%) showed simultaneous responses in both parameters. Twenty-eight tests (39%) contained a fall in tcPO 2 >3 kPa but six of these also showed a significant rise. Fifty-three tests (75%) contained a fall in tcPO 2 >15%, but 20 of these also showed a significant rise.Tracheal/chest auscultation with Sa,O 2 monitoring is a sensitive and relatively safe end-point for bronchial challenges in preschool children. The erratic pattern of transcutaneous oxygen pressure response in some children casts doubt on its reliability as a proxy measure of bronchial obstruction. Eur Respir J 1999; 14: 1175±1178. The measurement of bronchial responsiveness in preschool children is a potentially useful clinical and research tool, but it is hampered by the fact that lung function measurement in preschool children is technically difficult without sedation. Several indirect methods have been used to assess bronchial responsiveness to methacholine challenge in this age group. Tracheal or chest auscultation can be used to measure the provocative concentration of methacholine which induces audible wheeze (PCW) [1,2]. This technique does not require full co-operation of the children, and it has been demonstrated in older children that the value for PCW was similar to that causing a 20% fall in forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) [2]. Other authors have favoured measuring the transcutaneous oxygen tension (tcPO 2 ), arguing that it is effort independent, reliable and repeatable and is superior to tracheal auscultation [3±5]. The methodology of the study by WILSON et al. [4] involved cessation of challenge when tcPO 2 fell by 20%, which may have censored the PCW data.As part of a dose-ranging study of inhaled salmeterol in preschool children [6], the current study set out to reevaluate these two challenge endpoints. The aim of the study was to compare the sensitivity and safety of using audible wheeze and tcPO 2 in a methacholine challenge in children <4 yrs of age.
Methods
SubjectsChildren aged <4...