The challenge of defining and counting generalist physicians: an analysis of Physician Masterfile data.

Abstract

OBJECTIVES. The study reviewed methods for measuring the specialty distribution of the US physician workforce. It was hypothesized that current databases and measurement conventions overestimate the number of generalist physicians. METHODS. A descriptive analysis of the American Medical Association (AMA) Physician Masterfile for California was done with different assumptions about the definition of generalists based on primary and secondary specialty information. RESULTS. A rigorous definition of generalist physician that excludes physicians with secondary practices in specialist fields resulted in an estimate of generalist physicians 25% lower than the number estimated by conventional workforce evaluation methods. Physicians who reported practicing in both generalist and specialist fields were more likely to be older, to be international medical school graduates, and to be in solo or duo practice compared with physicians who listed only generalist or specialist fields. CONCLUSIONS. The actual number of generalist physicians in the United States may be less than previously believed. Although the exact magnitude of the "hidden system" of specialists providing primary care is difficult to measure, at least a portion appear to already be counted as generalist physicians by current conventions.

Associations of Physician Supplies with Colon Cancer Care in Ontario and California, 1996 to 2006

“…Primary care physicians in both countries were defined as those who reported their primary specialty area as general practice or family practice. Consistent with previously validated primary care definitions and prevalent practice patterns, general internists in California and emergency family medicine physicians in Ontario were also included [7,8,[47][48][49]. Physicians in either country who reported that the majority of their clinical time was spent in the practice of gastroenterology or who were board-certified gastroenterologists were defined as such.…”

Changes In Physician Supply And Scope Of Practice During A Malpractice Crisis: Evidence From Pennsylvania

“…8 Because providers are legally required to participate in MCARE, the database contains information on all actively practicing physicians. But because participation is costly, physicians who are not actively practicing generally are not represented.…”

Confidence of primary care physicians in assessing the suicidality of geriatric patients

“…A probability sample of physicians was obtained using the American Medical Association (AMA) Physician Master®le, a continuously updated source of data on all physicians in the United States (Grumbach et al, 1995). Retirees, students, and physicians who were not currently in practice were excluded.…”