The challenges of rural family physician program in Iran: a discourse analysis of the introduction to criticizing power imbalance between rural health and mainstream urban health

Abstract

Compared with many metropolitan residents, Iranians living in rural areas have a poorer health status partly due to the inequitable access to healthcare services. However, despite policy efforts to ameliorate the disparities, the gap in healthcare between rural and urban residents is growing wider according to several published studies. Among the fundamental causes of these disparities, dominant discourses play a critical role. This paper seeks to unpack the relations of power operated by socio-politically constructed discourses around rural health-promoting interventions, including rural Family Physician Program (FPP). We adopted a Foucauldian Discourse Analysis (FDA) to examine how well-intentioned efforts to advance equity policy may unintentionally maintain discourse and practices that reinforce inequity. We followed the analytic steps, outlined by Carabine, for distinguishing discourses in order to select and analyze 25 documents, 31 interviews, and 21 observations. The analysis revealed three interconnected discourses with supporting roles constructed in opposition to the putative role of the designed program: the rural FPP to achieve the government’s ideological purposes about justice and equality (the discourse of deficits), the rural FPP to align with the urban-oriented medical curriculum (the discourse of career disadvantages) and the rural FPP to represent discipline perceptions about rural communities (the discourse of rural inferiority). These oppositional role constructions can hinder the proper functioning of this policy, usually in favor of urban claims on rural space.

The causal effect of family physician program on the prevalence, screening, awareness, treatment, and control of hypertension and diabetes mellitus in an Eastern Mediterranean Region: a causal difference-in-differences analysis

“…This may be due to non-pharmaceutical therapies, such as improving lifestyle and decreasing diet-related risk factors, such as eating a balanced diet, engaging in regular physical activity, and avoiding alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs. Furthermore, the lack of awareness regarding NCDs can result in delayed treatment, making it crucial for Family Physicians (FPs) to raise awareness, encourage lifestyle changes and promote regularity in taking pharmaceutical treatment [ 45 , 46 ].…”