The Change4Life Convenience Store Programme to Increase Retail Access to Fresh Fruit and Vegetables: A Mixed Methods Process Evaluation

Abstract

BackgroundConsumption of fruit and vegetables is important for health, but is often lower than recommended and tends to be socio-economically patterned with lower consumption in more deprived groups. In 2008, the English Department of Health introduced the Change4Life convenience store programme. This aimed to increase retail access to fresh fruit and vegetables in deprived, urban areas by providing existing convenience stores with a range of support and branded point-of-sale materials and equipment.MethodsWe undertook a mixed-methods study of the Change4Life convenience store programme in the North East of England around two years after initial implementation. Store mapping (n = 87; 100% stores) and systematic in-store observations (n = 74; 85% stores) provided information on intervention fidelity; the variety, purchase price and quality of fresh fruit and vegetables on sale; and purchase price compared to a major supermarket. Ten qualitative interviews with a purposive sample of retailers and other professionals explored experiences of the intervention and provided further insight on quantitative results.ResultsIntervention stores were primarily located in socio-economically disadvantaged areas. Fidelity, in terms of presence of branded materials and equipment, was low and much was not being used as intended. Fresh fruit and vegetables on sale were of high quality and had a purchase price around 10% more than comparable products at a major supermarket.Interviewees were supportive of the health improvement aim of the intervention. Retailers were appreciative of part-funding for chill cabinets and free point-of-sale materials. The intervention suffered from: poor initial and on-going communication between the intervention delivery team and retailers; poor availability of replacement point-of-sale materials; and failure to cement intended links with health workers and community organisations.ConclusionsOverall, intervention fidelity was low and the intervention is unlikely to have had a substantial or long-term effect on customers’ consumption of fruit and vegetables.

Identifying the Effects of Environmental and Policy Change Interventions on Healthy Eating

“…Strategies to change retailer food stocking and display practices include offering incentives to provide more healthy foods and produce (16, 40), improving mechanisms and offering incentives for purchasing food from local farms (66), monitoring or purchasing refrigeration units for the storage of perishable produce items (66), placement of healthy foods within the store (1, 16, 36, 40), and point-of-purchase promotion of healthy foods and produce (1, 36). Implementation of these strategies may also require operation within higher policy-level domains.…”

“…Some success has been demonstrated for interventions among small grocery retailers using a combination of product placement and promotion strategies, with reported small increases in sales of fruits and vegetables among specific customers (1). …”

“…The most popular strategy evidenced in the literature was the implementation of price discounts for healthy food (38, 43, 92), whereas a few studies also attempted in-store sampling and cooking demonstrations of healthy food items (1, 36). Although there is currently no evaluation data available for in-store taste demonstration strategies, the use of price discounts has been consistently associated with changing food purchasing in several studies (38, 76, 89).…”

Effect of home vegetable gardening on the household availability of fruits and vegetables

“…An even more urgent need to intervene in very harsh realities from the socio-economic point of view has been consistently highlighted even in richer countries [9]. In Brazil, the consumption of fruit and vegetable does not reach even one-third of the minimum recommended daily intake of 400g.…”

Sugars and health: a review of current evidence and future policy

“…Development into a modern and efficient sector led to sugar becoming cheap and 41 plentiful from that time (1) and sugar consumption grew exponentially. Based on sales data, at 42 its peak approximately 50kg of sugar was purchased per year per person in the 1970's (2) . This 43 equates to 130g every day or 500kcal per day although consumption has reduced over the 44 past few years and continues to decline (2) .…”