The Changing Discourse of City Plans: Rationalities of Planning in Perth, 1955–2010

Abstract

Abstract:i Plans are among the most durable products of planning, and as such offer a revealing window into the worlds of the planners of their time. In this paper we set out a methodology for viewing those worlds using critical discourse analysis (CDA). This method focuses on four key textual features of plans: construal of substance, construction of agency, generic structure, and presentation, enabling the investigator to go beyond thematic discourses and uncover the institutional, political and ideological role of planning during the time period in which plans are produced. We use this method to interrogate the changing rationalities governing planning in Western Australia since the Second World War by analysing the four major city plans for Perth, covering a period from 1955 to 2010. This longitudinal analysis suggests that planning in WA mirrors concurrent trends in international planning theory, and highlights the significance of "the plan" as an object of inquiry for revealing the changing nature of planning and planners over time.

Is There Space for Better Planning in a Neoliberal World? Implications for Planning Practice and Theory

“…In everyday public policy debates across the globe the capacity of public policy interventions, such as planning, to effect positive change has rarely appeared quite so constrained (see, for example recent studies in England, Sweden, Norway, Finland and Australia (Gunn and Hillier 2012, Hrelja 2011, Mäntysalo and Saglie 2010, MacCullum and Hopkins 2011. Currently in the United Kingdom (UK), more especially England 2 , planning faces stark challenges.…”

Perth punk and the construction of urbanity in a suburban city

“…Perth exemplifies the trends that have characterised the development of Australian cities in the postwar era, which Maccallum and Hopkinson (2011, p. 491) describe as ‘strong population growth, the low-density living “culture” of Australia, and a distinctive property development industry’. As a primarily suburban city, Perth has struggled with the notion of urbanity.…”

Analysing urban policy discourses using textometry: An application to French urban transport plans (2000–2015)

“…This is probably due to the time required for such research, and for organising and analysing the often very voluminous information on a particular subject. These limitations mean that most such research focuses on a particular case study and its results can rarely be generalised (MacCalum and Hopkins, 2011). In urban policy research, the comparative perspective appears to produce quality work.…”