“…Nonetheless, the importance of virtual mass force in LSFB processes was discussed in great detail by Ghatage et al (2014), and was shown to drastically affect LSFB stability, especially in the transition from homogeneous to heterogeneous flow regimes. Malone et al (2006Malone et al ( , 2007Malone et al ( , 2008 included the Magnus lift force in their CFD-DEM simulations of a LSFB, however, Blais & Bertrand (2015) comprehensively argued that Magnus force can be neglected in liquid-solid systems as particle rotation is hindered to a great degree by the surrounding liquid. No study has been conducted to date in CFD-DEM simulations of LSFBs that included Saffman lift force.…”