The consequences of hospital autonomization in Colombia: a transaction cost economics analysis

Abstract

Granting autonomy to public hospitals in developing countries has been common over recent decades, and implies a shift from hierarchical to contract-based relationships with health authorities. Theory on transactions costs in contractual relationships suggests they stem from relationship-specific investments and contract incompleteness. Transaction cost economics argues that the parties involved in exchanges seek to reduce transaction costs. The objective of this research was to analyse the relationships observed between purchasers and the 22 public hospitals of the city of Bogota, Colombia, in order to understand the role of relationship-specific investments and contract incompleteness as sources of transaction costs, through a largely qualitative study. We found that contract-based relationships showed relevant transaction costs associated mainly with contract incompleteness, not with relationship-specific investments. Regarding relationships between insurers and local hospitals for primary care services, compulsory contracting regulations locked-in the parties to the contracts. For high-complexity services (e.g. inpatient care), no restrictions applied and relationships suggested transaction-cost minimizing behaviour. Contract incompleteness was found to be a source of transaction costs on its own. We conclude that transaction costs seemed to play a key role in contract-based relationships, and contract incompleteness by itself appeared to be a source of transaction costs. The same findings are likely in other contexts because of difficulties in defining, observing and verifying the contracted products and the underlying information asymmetries. The role of compulsory contracting might be context-specific, although it is likely to emerge in other settings due to the safety-net role of public hospitals.

Studying the link between institutions and health system performance: a framework and an illustration with the analysis of two performance-based financing schemes in Burundi

“…Liu and Mills 2003) and the 'vertical integration' literature (e.g. Castano and Mills 2012). Instead, a research programme that addresses the central role of institutional arrangements in the organization of health systems and that recognizes that modifying them (in terms of design and enforcement) is precisely what health sector reform is about is pivotal to understanding and improving performance of health systems in LICs.…”

Fail to prepare and you can prepare to fail: the experience of financing path changes in teaching hospitals in Iran

“…The hospital autonomy policy fulfilled only one dimension of PPS, while neglecting other dimensions. The readiness of purchasers and reducing information asymmetries between providers (hospitals) and purchasers (insurance bodies) are important prerequisites of a successful PPS policy [ 46 ]. Hospital autonomy policy expected the hospitals to act as economic units, while the policy ignored the need for the development of effective market regulations mechanisms.…”

Role of Inventory Visibility on Performance of Manufacturing Sector in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Study in Kenya

“…According to Castano and Mills (2013) transaction cost theory is one of the key motivator of supply chain alignment in any organization. The transaction cost economics focuses on the organization of transactions that occur whenever a good or service is transferred from a provider (seller) to a user (buyer) across separate interface.…”