The contribution of open comments to understanding the results from the Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPS): A qualitative study

Abstract

IntroductionTo develop high-quality and safe healthcare, a good safety culture is an important feature of healthcare-providing structures. The objective of this study was to analyze the qualitative data of the comments section of a Hospital Survey on Patient Safety (HSOPS) questionnaire to clarify the answers given to the closed questions.MethodUsing the original data from a cross-sectional survey of 5,064 employees at a single university hospital in France, we conducted a qualitative study by analyzing the comments of a HSOPS survey and conducting in-depth interviews with 19 healthcare providers. We submitted the comments and the interviews to a thematic analysis.ResultsA total of 3,978 questionnaires were returned, with 247 comments collected. The qualitative analysis identified several structural failures. The main categories of the open comments were concordant with the lowest dimension scores found in the quantitative analysis. The most frequently reported failures were related to the staffing and hospital management support dimensions. The healthcare professionals perceived the lack of resources, including understaffing, as the major barrier to the development of a patient safety culture. Concrete organizational issues related to hospital handoffs and risk coordination were identified, such as transfers from the emergency departments and the lack of feedback following self-reporting of incidents.ConclusionThe analysis of the open comments complemented the HSOPS scores, increasing the level of detail in the description of the hospital’s patient safety culture. Combined with a classical quantitative approach used in HSOPS-based surveys, the qualitative analysis of open comments is useful to identify organizational weaknesses within the hospital.

An exploration of patient safety culture in Kuwait hospitals: a qualitative study of healthcare professionals' perspectives

“…Other factors that contributed to the underreporting of errors could be the limited resources and time that put staff under pressure to focus on the main tasks. This was consistent with the outcomes from a similar French qualitative study 40. In this regard, shortage of staff was noticed among all healthcare specialties and eventually increased HCPs' workload resulting in a stressful working environment.…”

Exploring the role of managers in the development of a safety culture in seven French healthcare facilities: a qualitative study

“…Our finding of a perception of insufficient support for patient safety from managers does not seem to have changed since earlier quantitative studies carried out in France [7,21,22]. Our results confirm those from a recent mixed-method study conducted in France that shown an association between, on the one hand, the patient safety culture dimensions scores, and on the other hand, the qualitative perception of SC by caregivers [35].…”

Determinants of patient safety culture among healthcare providers in the Upper East Region of Ghana

“…32,33 For instance, Boussat et al. 36 found staffing to be the most frequently reported failed patient safety culture dimension. This suggests that most of the respondents felt that staff allocation was not adequate to handle patient safety-related workload.…”