The crystalline complexes of trimesic acid with L-and DL-histidine, C6HIoN3 O+.C9H50 6.~3H6 O, are both orthorhombic and have essentially identical cell dimensions: a = 18.097 (7), b = 13.353 (5), c = 6.737 (4) A, Z = 4; however, the space groups are P212~21 and Pna21 respectively. The structure of the chiral complex has been determined (Mo Ka, 1148 unique reflections, R = 0.057). The closely related structure of the racemate was established by analogy from symmetry requirements. The structures contain hydrogen-bonded layers of trimesic acid and histidine moieties extending parallel to (001). The locations of the H atoms and the dimensions of the moieties show that there has been transfer of a proton from one carboxylic acid group of trimesic acid to a N atom of the imidazole ring. The layers contain cavities which are partially occupied by acetone molecules which are azimuthally disordered about their C=O axes. The name appropriate to the salt is accordingly L-(or DL-) histidinium trimesateacetone. The structures consist of ribbons of cations and anions extending along [010]. Each ribbon of cations has histidinium ions of one chirality only; in the L salt all ribbons are congruent while in the DL salt the chirality alternates in the [100] direction normal to the ribbon axis. systematic absences. It was thus evident that determination of the crystal structure of the chiral complex would establish that of the racemate by analogy, from symmetry requirements only.
ExperimentalCrystals of TMA. L-histidine--~ acetone (I) and TMA. DL-histidine-] acetone (II) were prepared separately by dissolving TMA and L-or DL-histidine in water-acetone solution. Bunches of fine transparent prismatic needles, elongated along [001 ], were obtained after the solutions were allowed to stand for a few days. A similar complex with DL-histidine, in which one water molecule replaces each one-third molecule of acetone, was prepared from water alone. As the acetonecontaining crystals gave better diffraction patterns than the water-containing crystals, the former were used for the structure analysis. After preliminary photography, a single crystal 0.10 x 0.15 x 0.40 mm was sealed in a capillary and mounted on a Philips PW 1100/20 fourcircle diffractometer with e slightly displaced from the ~0 axis. Cell dimensions were determined from 22 centered reflections. Crystal data are given in Table 1. The correct formula (i.e. including one third of an acetone molecule) was established by the structure analysis.