Albeit the socially recognised narcissistic personality disorder is documented to be prevalent within leaders in many organisations, the victims of narcissistic behaviours and their experiences have been explored much less. Aiming at understanding the effects of narcissistic management upon employees generally residing within narcissist victim traits as well as their reactions and coping mechanisms, this qualitative study voiced and thematically analysed the narratives of eight participants interviewed in the UK. Four overarching themes emerged: (a) narcissistic tactics; (b) interpersonal effects; (c) intrapersonal effects and (d) effects on work, suggesting that although submissive individuals have been considered a good match to dominant leaders in the past, this ‘fit’ does not always guarantee harmonic collaboration. Instead, it is argued that there are specific factors that can provide such synergy and concluded that only a sufficient level of psychological need satisfaction of both parties can lead to successful outcomes. Thus, this research contributes to clarifying the mechanism of interaction between narcissistic leaders and their victims in the workplace, further proposing ideas for practical application of its findings and future research that will explore unhealthy interpersonal relationships and create awareness for positive change.